[apollo1201]

A funny number for the score I wrote yesterday after a bidding error from opponents.

1S - p - 4H - p
7S - X - p - p
XX - all pass

-2 red

This illustrates a basic rule for n/b but also for all. Conventions are great (not all, though), but even greater is to play the same ones as partner. Opener played splinters but not responder in that case. The reason to XX except gifting us an extra 500 (at no MP cost for them) remains obscure to me, though. Maybe he was playing SOS redoubles but not his partner🤣🤣🤣

[pescetom]

It all looks very obscure to me. I find it hard to imagine what a natural 4H over 1S might be and even harder to imagine a 1S hand that can jump to grand after a splinter. Redouble is easier to understand, a beginner with a hot head or just messing around.

[Cyberyeti]

pescetom, on 2019-March-07, 09:53, said:

It all looks very obscure to me. I find it hard to imagine what a natural 4H over 1S might be and even harder to imagine a 1S hand that can jump to grand after a splinter. Redouble is easier to understand, a beginner with a hot head or just messing around.

AKxxxxx, Axxx, AK, void can pretty much jump to 7 opposite the splinter, but if partner has no spades would be in the -2 region

[apollo1201]

Cyberyeti, on 2019-March-07, 10:27, said:

AKxxxxx, Axxx, AK, void can pretty much jump to 7 opposite the splinter, but if partner has no spades would be in the -2 region

Yes opener had some kind of big lopsided 2-suiter with spade losers « covered » by the splinter but not as many hearts considering his partner had a wagon of them already! I didn’t focus that much on the hand given the misunderstanding and I am not even sure 7S was a good call. Tbh I didn’t want to step into their « explanation » after the scoring!

[rmnka447]

If the opponents were a long standing partnership, then the bidding error is one of those "a cow flew by" (coined by S. J. Simon) moments that occurs from time to time.

If the opponents were a relatively new or pick up partnership, then the partners ought to consider making other bids that might not be misconstrued. But that isn't necessarily fool proof either. In this case, a WJS to 3 ♥, if that's applicable followed by 4 ♥, if possible. In a 2/1 context maybe a forcing NT followed by ♥ bids.

If opener had cyberyeti's hand and there were any doubt about whether 4 ♥ were a splinter or not, opener might bid 5 NT. 5NT can only be pick a slam or some sort of GSF. Whatever responder bids would get you to the right strain.

OTOH, if opener has a big 2 suiter implying some sort of ♥ shortness, maybe opener should consider how likely it is that partner also has ♥ shortness.

[Cyberyeti]

rmnka447, on 2019-March-07, 21:16, said:

If the opponents were a long standing partnership, then the bidding error is one of those "a cow flew by" (coined by S. J. Simon) moments that occurs from time to time.

If the opponents were a relatively new or pick up partnership, then the partners ought to consider making other bids that might not be misconstrued. But that isn't necessarily fool proof either. In this case, a WJS to 3 ♥, if that's applicable followed by 4 ♥, if possible. In a 2/1 context maybe a forcing NT followed by ♥ bids.

If opener had cyberyeti's hand and there were any doubt about whether 4 ♥ were a splinter or not, opener might bid 5 NT. 5NT can only be pick a slam or some sort of GSF. Whatever responder bids would get you to the right strain.

OTOH, if opener has a big 2 suiter implying some sort of ♥ shortness, maybe opener should consider how likely it is that partner also has ♥ shortness.

A friend once played in a 1-0 fit at the 4 level thinking partner couldn't possibly have a splinter in these circumstances

[etha]

the only bidding misunderstanding I ever noticed from Lauria Versace was a 1♠ 4♥ auction presumably they had changed the meaning recently.

[pescetom]

etha, on 2019-March-08, 05:31, said:

the only bidding misunderstanding I ever noticed from Lauria Versace was a 1♠ 4♥ auction presumably they had changed the meaning recently.

I had a partner who was adamant we should maintain 1♠ 4♥ as natural, so we played 1M-3NT as splinter in the other major. Of course you can have a midsunderstanding over that, too.