[AyunuS]

http://tinyurl.com/jgbrql5

Advanced GIB, IMPs.

West has too good of a hand to pass and just sell out at 2♣. Also it contradicts that the opponents can't play anything undoubled below 2N. Is there any reason not to bid hearts?

[Stefan_O]

AyunuS, on 2016-April-30, 18:45, said:

Also it contradicts that the opponents can't play anything undoubled below 2N.

Yes, robot-west seems to have a misunderstanding with himself on this one

Also, this hand seems more appropriate for 2♥ in the first round, rather than XX.
XX should ideally show a 3 suiter with shortness in opener's suit -- or at least 443 in the unbid suits, with no other suitable bid.

[lycier]

Stefan_O, on 2016-May-01, 05:19, said:

Yes, robot-west seems to have a misunderstanding with himself on this one

More than one misunderstanding in this hand .
See my hand :

---

Now you see that west can't bid up to 4♥ because of another misunderstanding - east Gib should misunderstand 4♥ and regard it as a splinter raise to support ♠.
Here it would better make a new explanation on 4♥ : 6-card+♥,10+hcp, game values.

[johnu]

lycier, on 2016-May-01, 07:31, said:

f another misunderstanding - east Gib should misunderstand 4♥ and regard it as a splinter raise to support ♠.

LOL, GIB forgot about the previous round of bidding.

[lycier]

johnu, on 2016-May-01, 12:20, said:

LOL, GIB forgot about the previous round of bidding.

Lol, here I also found another interesting thing while I checked AyunuS' hand traveller :
Only one hand - only AyunuS made a takeout at first round, others passed in the other 15 hands and Gibs got 4♥ contract eventually.
No double, no trouble, we are easy to find two issues.
AyunuS, you are great, good job !