Help
West's 3♥ is described as unlimited, but East passes anyway. Either West's bid needs to be sharply lower, or this should be forcing. I sat East and was the only one who accepted, making, while the GIB field all passed.
Page 1 of 1
passed hand 1s-2h inconsistency
#1
- Group: Advanced Members
- Posts: 4,100
- Joined: 2003-May-14
Posted 2012-April-13, 14:46
West's 3♥ is described as unlimited, but East passes anyway. Either West's bid needs to be sharply lower, or this should be forcing. I sat East and was the only one who accepted, making, while the GIB field all passed.
#2
- Group: Advanced Members
- Posts: 1,529
- Joined: 2008-December-02
Posted 2012-April-13, 15:27
Stephen Tu, on 2012-April-13, 14:46, said:
West's 3♥ is described as unlimited, but East passes anyway. Either West's bid needs to be sharply lower, or this should be forcing. I sat East and was the only one who accepted, making, while the GIB field all passed.
Not described as unlimited but as with as wide a HCP range as an opening hand so basically little extra information over an opening hand.
#3
- Group: Admin
- Posts: 21,600
- Joined: 2004-August-21
- Gender:Male
Posted 2012-April-13, 17:06
This is a bug. The rule for responder distinguishes between passed and unpassed hand, but the rule for opener's 3♥ rebid doesn't. So it's making the 3♥ bid that it would have made after a GF 3♥, showing extra values.
#4
- Group: Advanced Members
- Posts: 2,553
- Joined: 2005-April-25
Posted 2012-April-14, 10:20
Stephen Tu, on 2012-April-13, 14:46, said:
.
West's 3♥ is described as unlimited, but East passes anyway. Either West's bid needs to be sharply lower, or this should be forcing. I sat East and was the only one who accepted, making, while the GIB field all passed.
West's 3♥ is described as unlimited, but East passes anyway. Either West's bid needs to be sharply lower, or this should be forcing. I sat East and was the only one who accepted, making, while the GIB field all passed.
....and I think what you will find that in the main room the results are all over the place...anytime a human sits where GIB usually is the results change...from leads to bids. the only place there is consistency is in robot pay tourneys where all humans sit south....so I am talking about who sits where not what GIBs 3♥ bid is.
Page 1 of 1