[myprac]

The rollover description for a 1nt opener says "Could have 5M." The text version of GIB's convention card says a 1nt opener denies a 5-card major. I recall an announcement a while back that GIB was changed to permit 5M for 1nt, so I assume it is the CC that requires correction. Would be nice to get some clarity on how GIB chooses between 1nt and 1M.

[myprac]

And here's another inconsistency. The CC says "Opening major rebid does not promise 6 cards in the suit." In the sequence 1H - 1S - 2H the rollover for the last bid says 6+ H.

[Bbradley62]

myprac, on 2011-November-05, 12:28, said:

And here's another inconsistency. The CC says "Opening major rebid does not promise 6 cards in the suit." In the sequence 1H - 1S - 2H the rollover for the last bid says 6+ H.

That's because 1N is available for the minimum balanced rebid. But, the sequence 1H-2C/2D-2H doesn't show 6 because 2N would show extras.

[barmar]

I'll see what I can do about fixing the notes and CC for the 1NT and 2NT openings.

As Bradley says, the point about rebids not promising 6 only applies in 2/1 auctions. I'll try to get that fixed as well.

[myprac]

barmar, on 2011-November-05, 20:58, said:

I'll try to get that fixed as well.

Thanks. And BTW, my remarks aren't complaints and I hope they aren't too nitpicky. Just trying to contribute toward improvements, even if minor ones.