Posted 2011-July-19, 05:52
Out of curiosity i manually went through ''some'' boards.
Not sure how objective it is, but quite often opponents had 5♣+3Aces tricks and were able to get his 9th trick.
From my observations most likely chances for defense appears when partner has
......5♠ or 5♦ with some support from partner,
while partner will have 5♠ more often, it would be reasonably bettter to hit ♦Axxxx rather than ♠Axxxx (and ♦Jxxxx rather than ♠Jxxxx); note that ♠A+J won't improve your chances by much (only T-Qxx split), additional T would be much better (AJTxx with partner) though.
......♠AJxx (AJx) if we can get 4 from top,
if LHO has ♥A, opponents can probably still get their 9 tricks: 5♣+3♥+1♦ or more unlikely 4♣+4♥+1♦
...... ♦Axxx (Axx)
same reasons
......♦J+any ace gives reasonable chances (also T does, because declarer quite frequently will finesse T rather than KQ)
this would be a good card to hit, there probably are reasonable chances to to set them with additional slow tricks in other suits.
......♠ QJxx, QJx, QTxx etc.
+some heart support like ♥Q9x gives some reasonable chances (depends in which suit declarer will try to get his 9th trick and where these red aces are), so does ♣ Qxx.
Overall i think it is quite close, but i lean towards small ♦.
Seeking input from anyone who doesn't frequently "wtp", "Lol" or post to merely "Agree with ..." --sathyab
jschafer asked...
They play 13-16 NT but their responses are standard. IMPs.
Does your lead change if it is MPs?
IMO
At teams, ♠ = 10, ♦ = 8, ♥ = 7
At pairs, ♠ = 10, ♣ = 7.