Posted 2011-February-26, 13:58
Partner may have been trying to decide between 7♥ and 7nt.
Partner is captain for sure and that suggests passing. But what can partner have to force to the 5 level opposite a 15-17 nt with 3 hearts?
I'm assuming 2♦ is game forcing nmf, which maybe it isn't, but surely partner can investigate slam some other way. If we assume partner doesn't have any K and only has 5 hearts then what is the hand he could have where he'd jump to 4nt?
Would something like:
Axxx
KQxxx
Axx
x
jump to 4nt? 13 opposite 15 in an 8 card fit might not be safe at the 5 level, especially if there are wasted club values.
If you J it up you get:
AJxx
KQJxx
AJx
J
And now you have 16 which would probably be willing to try 4nt and would leave you in grand which would be on a ♠ finesse or a ♣ finnese or a ♣+♠ squeeze (only get to choose one).
But if partner has a 6-th heart, or partner has either black K (probably spades on the auction) then we are home free. And partner doesn't know about our diamond source of tricks.
So I think I'd bid it.