Imperfections on BBO Constructive Critiscm's
#1
Posted 2011-February-12, 01:50
to give us our daily injections.
Subject-------Clocked or unclocked Tourneys. A
Chat open or closed. B
very suspicios-Suspect dare i say it Cheating. C
A Either,Am i correct Experts in unclocked Tourneys slow the bidding
down,to gain an advantage of meeting slow players in the next round's.
but, not in all cases.if one is reasonably quick,its also surprising.how
many experts- one also gets in subsequent rounds.
and the tactic same country an expert always with a novice/beginner.same
country.then another Tactic one profile states Sayc blah blah.
the other profile states precision-Then the dealer{SAYC} opens 1cl-
non alert.so now one has to ask opps which system is in use?
if clocked Tourneys 2/3/boardsif an opp considers a bad result coming up,
be it board 2 or 3 refusing to play to a card plyd by declarer,another
tatic. {Known as time wasting they get an average board}
B chat open---we shoot ourselves in the foot sometimes.with comments coming up
in the chat referring to the first second hand,poeple can take advantage.
agree to their own peril---suggest we all keep stum.amd chat should only
be open if one has finnshed early,then it should be not available to all.
There shld be less "You Tube" music it clutters up the atmosphere.
C..............As a kibber was kibbing tourney 1141 i think hand 2 a friend,
they n/s north opened 1n/t sayc 15-17.can see a slam coming up.E-pass-South
Stayman 2cl--west pass-N 2 hts E-pass-S-3hts--W--pass N 4n/t {slam coming up
S 5cl--WEST PASS--N 6hts--pass--pass W x west holds 4/3/5/1 SHDC total points
2 a stiff Qcl-rest 9 high norths hand 4/4/1/4 total points 4 one ace
the rest 0 your lead as East----??? 1n/t--P--2cl--P
2hts--P--3hts-P
4n/t--P--5cl--P
6hts--P--x --P
"This life is a Test-it is only a Test,Further instructions on where to go,and
what to do will be NOTIFED"
i think chats shld be banned during tourney,sometimes it 6/8 boads,helps to keep
a level ply field.and results shld be anylysed,to cut out cheating.one person i
would monitor is west who x 6hts with ZILCH.he/she had 2/3 comuters running,or a kibber
advising
#3
Posted 2011-February-12, 05:20
pirate22, on 2011-February-12, 01:50, said:
down,to gain an advantage of meeting slow players in the next round's.
If they all do it, they'll meet each other in the next round.
London UK
#4
Posted 2011-February-12, 06:21
#5
Posted 2011-February-12, 09:35
#6
Posted 2011-February-12, 17:17
inquiry, on 2011-February-12, 09:35, said:
Well, zilch may be perfectly innocent.
But the guy named sitout is a real runner.
He is never logged on at game time, so i know and never invite.
#7
Posted 2011-February-12, 20:02
babalu1997, on 2011-February-12, 17:17, said:
But the guy named sitout is a real runner.
He is never logged on at game time, so i know and never invite.
#8
Posted 2011-February-13, 22:38
mtvesuvius, on 2011-February-12, 02:01, said:
I think that he has several concerns:
1) Experts who deliberately play slowly to try to avoid the other experts who play fast.
2) An expert playing with a novice, and have different systems in their profiles, so you have to ask what they play. I don't understand this one (can't you just ask that they alert, the partner doesn't see alerts), nor do I understand why the point is made that they are from the same country, nor that they have disparate self-ratings.
3) Chat to whole tournaments giving away things in specific hands. And also that it's a lot of noise (ironic, huh, given the post)?
4) Something specific about a hand that I am not interested in thinking hard enough about to translate.
Honestly, Shubi was easier because at least his were shorter!
#9
Posted 2011-February-15, 10:21
if there is a player named zilch my apologies.
I also noticed someone giving an example ABC and XYZ but he also pointed this
out in case someone uses this as a handle")")
talk about protocol:)
#10
Posted 2011-February-22, 15:32