ONEferBRID, on Oct 14 2010, 02:09 PM, said:
Opener has denied 4s with the 2H rebid.. AND has shown 6+h ( with only 5 cards, Opener would have had a 3C or 3D or 2NT rebid -- even if one of the unbid suits were unstopped [ as Phillip Alder would say: " that's what partners are for " ] ).
It is fairly common to play that after 2/1, 2M rebid doesn't promise 6+ cards, and that 1
♥-2
♣-2
♠ shows extra (which means 1
♥-2
♣-2
♥ doesn't deny 4 spades either). Of course that is not the only way of playing 2/1, but I think you will find plenty of players (and majority of experts) who DON'T play the way you described.
That being said, I do agree that 2
♠ is not a good bid. Once you decide to start the auction with 2
♣ (which has merits and problems), you should give up finding 4-4 spade fit after partner rebids 2
♥. The 2
♠ bid implies a much better club suit. I think a simple 2NT is best here. If partner raises to 3NT, you can bid quant 4NT. If partner rebids 3
♥ (as he should for this hand), you can start cuebidding.