What do you expect of the double and what is your call?
Another Patton bidding problem
#1
Posted 2010-May-19, 02:05
What do you expect of the double and what is your call?
#2
Posted 2010-May-19, 02:55
--Always remember you're unique. Just like everyone else.
#3
Posted 2010-May-19, 03:04
London UK
#4
Posted 2010-May-19, 03:21
#6
Posted 2010-May-19, 04:03
#7
Posted 2010-May-19, 04:39
If we don't usually open 1NT with a 5-card major, he might have a 3523 16-count.
#8
Posted 2010-May-19, 05:13
#9
Posted 2010-May-19, 06:05
East4Evil ♥ sohcahtoa 4ever!!!!!1
#10
Posted 2010-May-19, 06:27
Kx
axxxx
Ax
akxx
gives slam. ok, it's 18 with prime controls but it's a crappy shape. 5C is pretty likely imo.
time to jump to 4C and punish the opps for protecting.
#11
Posted 2010-May-19, 06:41
3C for me.
If X is cooperative and an offer to play 2DX if we have 3+ diamonds I'll pass. Seems like this could work as well as 3C and may be more fun, if not at the table then in the PM.
#12
Posted 2010-May-19, 07:11
hanp, on May 19 2010, 03:05 AM, said:
1H - p - 1S - p
2C - p - p - (2D)
Dbl - p - ??
What do you expect of the double and what is your call?
I call 3♣ Double? what double?
the Freman, Chani from the move "Dune"
"I learned long ago, never to wrestle with a pig. You get dirty, and besides, the pig likes it."
George Bernard Shaw
#13
Posted 2010-May-19, 07:32
#14
Posted 2010-May-19, 07:43
#15
Posted 2010-May-19, 07:57
♥ x
♦ 10xx
♣ Q10xxx
1H - p - 1S - p
2C - p - p - (2D)
Dbl - p - ??
The only reasonable reason for the X is take out and near top for previous 2c bid and almost assuredly a hand with 2 spades or less (way too easy to bid 2s over 2d)
but not so distributional that defending 2d is out of the question (we might choose 3c with such a hand vs x). My best guess is a hand similar to x AKxxx xx AKxxx
or maybe even a tad stronger. Since my original pass over 2c might have been made with xx (vs void in hearts) suddenly my useful ACE and FIVE CARD trump support and SHORTNESS in hearts with massive trump fit a hand that was easily worth 3c over 2c (if p can realize it might be a distribution based raise) must now come alive and bid 5c and the opps will cower in fear about ever reopening again against us.
#16
Posted 2010-May-19, 08:25
bed
#17
Posted 2010-May-19, 08:32
My choice is between 4♣ or 3♦.
I think 3♦ may not be clear at all so I am going with 4♣ for the sake of simplicity (I assume 2♣ is natural promising 4+)
#19
Posted 2010-May-19, 10:11
Now I cannot bid less than 4♣. We have boxed our hand and its inconceivable that 10 tricks isn't easy.
4♣ eliminates 3N as an option however, so 3♦ should at least be considered. 3N seems easier across from a hand like: xx AKxxx Ax AKxx, although this hand seems well-picked. Maybe others can come up with better examples of hands where 3N is far superior to 5♣.
Winner - BBO Challenge bracket #6 - February, 2017.
#20
Posted 2010-May-19, 10:14
bed
1H - p - 1S - p
2C - p - p - (2D)
Dbl - p - ??