Codo, on Jan 14 2010, 09:53 AM, said:
Old York, on Jan 11 2010, 02:15 AM, said:
Quote "You continue with transfers. "
I have seen the bid made many times showing both majors, but not showing a maximum. Perhaps this is the problem.
1NT-2♣-2NT-3♠(trf)-4♥ going 1 down was bad when opener was minimum
Tony
I have seen the bid made many times showing both majors, but not showing a maximum. Perhaps this is the problem.
1NT-2♣-2NT-3♠(trf)-4♥ going 1 down was bad when opener was minimum
Tony
Interessting way to play transfer with 3 ♠ tzo show hearts.
As Td, I had been called to the table by opponents. I have no idea what 3♠ actually showed and doubt that anyone at the table knew. It is possible that it was intended to show 4 bad spades and 5 hearts, some sort of smolen bid, dunno
My decision was "no agreement-no damage-result stands"
The point of this thread, and this hand, is that players are rebidding 2NT with no agreement, confusing partner and opponents
Tony